Monday, March 30

two characters

Our university tried bridging the humanities and the science for just one day with a program they called "Imagining, Performing, Writing Science." Rather than be dismissive, it didn't seem to be to much of a burden to attend. When I looked more carefully at the schedule, I saw that the post-lunch presentation was by the guys who host RadioLab on WNYC. Jad Abumrad and Robert Krulwich in person ... at UConn. One fascinating aspect was that in person, they engage in the same overlapping talk when live as they do on their radio show. And it was an investment of just 90 minutes of a Friday afternoon.

After they played their first audio clip from their show, I realized that they hadn't generated anything necessarily new for our cow college. Given the spontaneous laughter from the audience and the horrid intro by a physics professor (who confessed he'd only learned about RadioLab two weeks prior) I can't fault them for their decision. While I did record their presentation, you can hear a very high quality version by listening to their Sept 9, 2008 show called "Making the Hippo Dance." Some slightly different quips but the bulk of the presentation is the same. Not bad, but less than I had hoped for. At least for the content.

What intrigued me was that there were two roles being played and they were not accidental. On different programs they swap these roles. The roles are "science enthusiast" and "skeptical realist."
The dialogue creates a fascinating space into which the listener can insert himself. So one guy will say something like, "Even though there's no biological basis to race, forensic scientists can determine gender and race from a tissue sample" and then the other guy will say, "Wait wait WAIT! That can't be possible. How can this be?" And then the other guy will slowly reel in his faux resistance friend. The effect is that I get pulled in, too. Great storytelling and I'll bet there's even a name for this rhetorical device -- but all I know about rhetoric is what I just read at the site A Handbook of Rhetorical Devices (maybe I'll attempt a "dirimens copulatio" without being slapped?). But I digress ...

With a major conference address on the horizon, less than 3 weeks hence, I have wondered about how the co-presenters might represent subtly different stances toward grand challenges and great opportunities. Imagine two speakers. One represents the senior, frustrated and demanding person who tries to incite the crowd; the other speaker a younger, joyous, and encouraging fellow who tries to offer insights. The former could insist that the solution is to tear down the temple while the other might point to rays of hope that might affect changes from within. The former could rant about shelves of volumes and issues of publications that have had little affect; the latter could suggest that there are voluminous issues that demand our attention. One could propose a revolution against the traditional conference; his foil could point to gentler efforts of resistance that are less destructive? Missed opportunities and wasted efforts ... or greater clarity about what we should do and fresh commitments to doing these kinds of works.

Wednesday, March 25

awesome interview prompts for science educators

Given that science educators frequently invoke Star Wars references within conversations, it was tempting to imagine an interview protocol in which prompts made use of this (sadly) common experience. I could not resist the temptation. What I did resist was creating hyperlinks throughout the transcripts:
Q: Do you remember Star Wars Episode Six?
A: The Return of the Jedi? Yeah, that was awesome.
Q: Yeah, it WAS awesome. Remember during the Ewok’s bonfire party and Luke sees the gossamer images of Obi-Wan Kenobi, Yoda and the redeemed Anakin Skywalker?
A: Yeah, Luke built his father’s funeral pyre.
Q: Yep. Which people in your professional life are represented by those three figures?
The preceding exchange was inspired by an actual interview between two science educators. In the original, it was the interviewee who invoked Star Wars. In contrast, the following is what I imagine would occur if a researcher asked a science educator to describe the factors that prompted leaving the classroom in order to pursue an academic career.
Q: Remember the Empire Strikes Back?
A: Yeah, that was awesome. That battle on the ice planet Hoth was incredible!
Q: Remember when Luke flew from Hoth to Dagobah?
A: Yep, to train with Yoda.
Q: Exactly! What phase of your professional life is represented by Luke’s visit by Obi-Wan who told him how to be trained as a Jedi?
The following exchange about "midi-cholrians" is not based upon a phenomenon I actually remembered from seeing the movie. It just happened to emerge while doing research for this blog entry. I'm not saying that I am too hip to not know this -- just that I was too old when I first watched Episode 1. If I was younger, then I suspect I would have asked my science teacher about whether midi-chlorians could be real. If they were, that would be awesome! The image is from Wookieepedia.
Q: Remember in the Phantom Menace where they talked about midi-chlorians? A: Yeah, that was awesome. That provided was a cellular level explanation of the Force.
Q: Yes. And that’s how the Jedi Council knew that Anakin Skywalker was a future Jedi.
A: And Luke had a high midi-chlorian count, too.
Q: Indeed. What aspect of your professional life has similarities to the idea of midi-cholrians?

Thursday, March 19

touch of love and pride beyond mere skill = art

This is why the attainment of proficiency, the pushing of your skill with attention to the most delicate shades of excellence, is a matter of vital concern. Efficiency of a practically flawless kind may be reached naturally in the struggle for bread. But there is something beyond—a higher point, a subtle and unmistakable touch of love and pride beyond mere skill; almost an inspiration which gives to all work that finish which is almost—which, in fact, is art.
Joseph Conrad, 1906
The Mirror of the Sea, p. 26

Wednesday, March 18

instant community by invitation

That newcomers to Crossroads are so immediately incorporated into the larger group has been mentioned enough times that it has become noteworthy. This phenomenon has been reported by novice attendees but has also been noted by those who are Crossroads veterans. Within "legitimate peripheral participation" is the possibility that apprentices must linger and lurk at the edges. This isn't anything a true scholar of Lave & Wenger would propose. Instead, it comes from my early and painful experiences as a wallflower at research conferences. It seems to take years to move from the periphery into the community and that might be an artifact of the move from apprentice to journeyman to master. Because this transition happens so suddenly at Crossroads, it suggests that something unique is at play. I have an hypothesis.

Everybody who comes to Crossroads has been pre-approved. Whether we actually have done so or not, the assumption by the community is that each newcomer has been hand-selected and specially invited to join the event. Like the holders of golden tickets, there is no guantlet to pass through in order to qualify as a legitimate member of the group. By virtue of their very presence, each new arrival is embraced as bona fide and worthy. How wonderful it must be to arrive, nervous about one's legitimacy yet excited to share with others -- and then to become one of the crowd even before anybody knows your name. And what great pressure that puts on those who distribute the invitations.

I suspect that this is one of the magic aspects of Crossroads: everyone who has attended was specially invited and usually through a face-to-face conversation. The personalized recruitment has continued since this project's inception. But until recently, I was only partially aware of the sense of coming together of old and new. And I had not recognized how instantly everything went "into solution" -- without stirring, with warming up, without waiting. This also becomes a self-fulfilling prophesy because those who we did not personally invited (known only to us) were accepted as if they were because no one knew any different. The effect was the same. Perhaps the invitations themselves are as important as many of the other aspects of this process.

Sunday, March 15

Chi Rho Delta fraternity

One of our recent interview questions aims to uncover the distinguishing characteristics of the Crossroads community. A year ago, our research revealed that it doesn't carry some of the indicators of being a community of practice. So we cleverly couched social dimension as a "practice community." Having postulated that aspect, we have been inquiring to see how our participants recognize the practice and the community. We continue to run into barriers.

The contentiousness over "practice" is harder to unpack. But "community" elicits a range of perspectives. Some assert that it is indeed a community with all the interrelationships and interpersonal supports. Others view its short duration as a reason it does not qualify as a community. Alternative have been suggested included that it is a family -- presumably a family with two daddies.

It was the suggestion that Crossroads is more like a fraternity or sorority (science pants or science dresses) that got me thinking. What would be the Greek letters on the outside our house? What would be emblazoned on our shirts -- and appear on the sides of our homecoming float? Three letters: XRD as in Chi Rho Delta. It sounds a little odd, as if it's a geography clue on Jeopardy: Cairo Delta. But think about how those three letters would like spraypainted against the side of the Orange County Hyatt next month. Tagged!

Saturday, March 14

short time off

A nearby town had its Maple Festival this weekend. In the settled part of the village (by the grocery store and strip mall) there were booths selling fried dough and doing face painting. The addition of "maple" barely distinguishes this festival from any other festival in other parts of our fine country. We did drive into the hinterlands to visit a couple of sugar shacks. One looked real authentic but they were only boiling water to show how the system worked. The other was really making syrup from sap but with gas heat rather than wood. Neither place resulted in a good photo.

All was not a loss: I snapped this picture out the window. And on our way home, we stopped at the supermarket where I discovered one of my advisees working as a cashier. She promised to let me know when she's delivering a good lesson during student teaching and I promised to do what I could to come visit. A very short break from work but a break nonetheless.

Thursday, March 12

personality is a bigger part than I knew

Personality is as much a part of Gee's Nature-identity as race, gender or dialect. It took me quite a long time to recognize that being a White, mono-lingual male is a significant part of who I am and how others recognize me. But until recently, I felt my outlook and dispositions were little more than surface features. The only time I really notice or actively manage my personality is when I trot out the charming, compassionate and intellectual self when I meet knew people and try to bend them to do my bidding (e.g., offering me a job or opening their school to my grad students). Apparently it has been wrong to believe the parts of me that are "just who I am" are mere decorations. Not that I need to advertise how powerful those traits are — I'll leave that to my publicist.

Our little project called Crossroads has been something I have been trying to export almost as soon as the inaugural gathering was over. Foolishly, I have suggested that the movement is bigger than me and that others could simply follow our model and use it for purposes that are similar in spirit but specific to particular needs. No one has taken us up on that offer. Up until now, I think we've interpreted this as a profound lack of gumption. Admittedly, there is considerable work involved but it's a relatively manageable task -- and any errors are unlikely to induce genuine pain or anything life-threatening. Find someone to build a webpage, identify a quirky yet comfortable conference site, sculpt participants' work so it will be accessible to their audience, and find yourself a decent poet. What are you: scared?! No, it's because they aren't me.

It is time to own up to the fact that the co-organizers' personalities are perhaps the most significant aspect of this project. Sure we are really conscientious about getting people from the airport to the conference site. Yes, we are sufficiently adept writers that we can encourage others to revise their initial efforts. True, we are empathetic to the need for decent meals, great snacks and inspiring settings. But what it really comes down to, what truly seems to make it all work as it does, is because the combined personalities of the leaders are manifested throughout the entire event. Actually, this extends long before and far beyond a given meeting. It includes our efforts at alluring new people to attend and it reverberates as attendees encourage their most trusted of colleagues to consider coming next year. Except for a few holdouts, even poetry seems to be be a surrogate for our personalities and that assists in creating a climate in which the magic can occur. This joins with our capacity to juxtapose humor (and joy and delight) against seriousness (and determination and outrage). We live and breathe these paradoxes in our everyday life. What I am slowly ('cause I am slow) coming to recognize is that the glorious tensions we create is why it all works -- and that this is an extension of who we are no matter how much we might imagine that others could step up and fill our shoes. For now, we shouldn't worry about who is going to take our place. In truth, that may be an impossible hope because I am coming to accept that "I am me and my circumstances" and that my identity is so tightly enmeshed with my buddy's that Crossroads IS us.