Showing posts with label community. Show all posts
Showing posts with label community. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 18

instant community by invitation

That newcomers to Crossroads are so immediately incorporated into the larger group has been mentioned enough times that it has become noteworthy. This phenomenon has been reported by novice attendees but has also been noted by those who are Crossroads veterans. Within "legitimate peripheral participation" is the possibility that apprentices must linger and lurk at the edges. This isn't anything a true scholar of Lave & Wenger would propose. Instead, it comes from my early and painful experiences as a wallflower at research conferences. It seems to take years to move from the periphery into the community and that might be an artifact of the move from apprentice to journeyman to master. Because this transition happens so suddenly at Crossroads, it suggests that something unique is at play. I have an hypothesis.

Everybody who comes to Crossroads has been pre-approved. Whether we actually have done so or not, the assumption by the community is that each newcomer has been hand-selected and specially invited to join the event. Like the holders of golden tickets, there is no guantlet to pass through in order to qualify as a legitimate member of the group. By virtue of their very presence, each new arrival is embraced as bona fide and worthy. How wonderful it must be to arrive, nervous about one's legitimacy yet excited to share with others -- and then to become one of the crowd even before anybody knows your name. And what great pressure that puts on those who distribute the invitations.

I suspect that this is one of the magic aspects of Crossroads: everyone who has attended was specially invited and usually through a face-to-face conversation. The personalized recruitment has continued since this project's inception. But until recently, I was only partially aware of the sense of coming together of old and new. And I had not recognized how instantly everything went "into solution" -- without stirring, with warming up, without waiting. This also becomes a self-fulfilling prophesy because those who we did not personally invited (known only to us) were accepted as if they were because no one knew any different. The effect was the same. Perhaps the invitations themselves are as important as many of the other aspects of this process.

Sunday, March 15

Chi Rho Delta fraternity

One of our recent interview questions aims to uncover the distinguishing characteristics of the Crossroads community. A year ago, our research revealed that it doesn't carry some of the indicators of being a community of practice. So we cleverly couched social dimension as a "practice community." Having postulated that aspect, we have been inquiring to see how our participants recognize the practice and the community. We continue to run into barriers.

The contentiousness over "practice" is harder to unpack. But "community" elicits a range of perspectives. Some assert that it is indeed a community with all the interrelationships and interpersonal supports. Others view its short duration as a reason it does not qualify as a community. Alternative have been suggested included that it is a family -- presumably a family with two daddies.

It was the suggestion that Crossroads is more like a fraternity or sorority (science pants or science dresses) that got me thinking. What would be the Greek letters on the outside our house? What would be emblazoned on our shirts -- and appear on the sides of our homecoming float? Three letters: XRD as in Chi Rho Delta. It sounds a little odd, as if it's a geography clue on Jeopardy: Cairo Delta. But think about how those three letters would like spraypainted against the side of the Orange County Hyatt next month. Tagged!

Wednesday, January 28

a place for community

A question (or challenge or doubt) has been raised whether it may be more difficult to describe the Ideal Place than it has been create such a space. This would be reasonable if the specialness was rare and unpredictable. But when such a place setting arises with regularity it is worth trying to capture the conditions that create this phenomenon. Further, that the Ideal Place consists of a substantial proportion of new participants and occurs in vastly different location -- it appears that comparing these distinct cases ought to shake out the common factors.

The conditions for the Ideal Place probably tap into a primal instinct. While somewhat fanciful, their existence in the world outside of children's stories suggests that the border between fiction and non-fiction may be a gray area. Or perhaps the special place is set within the very location that only appears to be a border: a hedgerow or a windbreak or a stone wall. Each of these cases might superficially designate a dividing line. However, those who look closely recognize the special and unique occurrences taking place in these interstitial zones.

A special place could be where a person goes on his own in order to enjoy the solitude. It is probably best for each person to find their own spot and not disclose its location or existence to others. However, another type of ideal place takes the form of a gathering. It would have to be more than an ordinary gathering because (at least in my mind) one aspect of the idealness would be that everyone involved would benefit from the experience. In fact, it might even be better if there was a shared sense about why to gather in the first place. As we are growing to appreciate, such topics were long ago explored by John Dewey:

Wherever there is conjoint activity whose consequences are appreciated as good by all singular persons who take part in it, and where the realization of the good is such as to effect an energetic desire and effort to sustain it in being just because it is a good shared by all, there is in so far a community.
~ The Search for the Great Community, 1927
Admittedly this does not describe how the Ideal Place may be established. But perhaps knowing the ends and their subtle characteristics, we can reconstruct the means. Maybe the secret is that we had an implicit sense for what we longed for within an Ideal Space and because our experiences and aspirations were so aligned with that of so many others, our boldness to act may have simply opened the door to what it was that so many others needed.