Showing posts with label tensions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tensions. Show all posts

Saturday, January 1

reaching an end

Endings and beginnings are very odd pairings. In some cases, a beginning is loud and dramatic while the end is indefinite and discrete. Examples include human life (the screaming moment of birth and the quiet exhalation at death) and the calendar year (fireworks for January 1 compared to a flipped calendar page for December 1). We celebrate new arrivals and weep at the departures.

In other cases, the transition from start to finish is a crescendo with the UConn Women’s Basketball team as a poignant example. Under great national attention, Stanford ended the Husky win streak at 90 games. [It was surreal to watch Condoleezza Rice celebrating, maybe vindicated for her failed Iraq efforts?] In contrast, our local PBS station just re-broadcasted the first game in the streak from November 16, 2008. It was a very typical game with no one sensing where it might all conclude, and nobody imagining that it would almost 1000 days later.


Each year, the media lists the more famous who have walked among us but have died over the preceding 12 months: actors, scientists, artists, etc. Almost inevitably, we are surprised to discover someone’s passing. People like the woman who played the wife and mother on Leave it To Beaver have been such a presence over the years that it is almost as startling to realize that she is a living person as to simultaneously discover that she is, finally and forever, not. As struck as we can be by an ending this is often followed by the sense that things continue. Maybe we believe the UConn win streak would go on forever, despite the coach making it clear that someday it would have to end. We were fooling ourselves into believing that there might be a basketball doxology:
As it was in the beginning
Is now, and ever shall be,
World without end …
On the night of the famous loss, I went to bed heavyhearted with condolences arriving through the ether. And the next morning we realized we were going to be okay. The coach was quick to recover, quipping at the post-game press conference: “This losing stuff is getting old: I hate it.” Other basketball games are on the schedule and we have six pairs of tickets on the refrigerator waiting to be used — including the first appearance by the team after their spanking by the Cardinal.

What remains unclear is whether anything new really begins and if endings are especially final. Stephen Jay Gould himself charted this by examining time as an arrow or as a cycle. In relation to geology, he appreciated the dichotomy of the metaphors and praised the tensions it generated. And that worked well for Dr Gould in his professional life; in his personal life he has ceased to be. And yet, he persists in his works which continue to education and enlighten.

An acquaintance expressed astonishment that I was not regularly archiving my computer files. I discovered I had the software that just need to be reloaded. The hardware was already on hand but never put into automatic action. I also ran an anti-virus program as recommended and came back with a completely clean bill of technological health. Now I can virtually thumb back through several years of syllabi and manuscripts and conference proceedings. But Time Machine only looks backwards. On January 1st, it is all about possibilities. I am curious to discover a year from now what has been added and what is changed.

Monday, March 30

two characters

Our university tried bridging the humanities and the science for just one day with a program they called "Imagining, Performing, Writing Science." Rather than be dismissive, it didn't seem to be to much of a burden to attend. When I looked more carefully at the schedule, I saw that the post-lunch presentation was by the guys who host RadioLab on WNYC. Jad Abumrad and Robert Krulwich in person ... at UConn. One fascinating aspect was that in person, they engage in the same overlapping talk when live as they do on their radio show. And it was an investment of just 90 minutes of a Friday afternoon.

After they played their first audio clip from their show, I realized that they hadn't generated anything necessarily new for our cow college. Given the spontaneous laughter from the audience and the horrid intro by a physics professor (who confessed he'd only learned about RadioLab two weeks prior) I can't fault them for their decision. While I did record their presentation, you can hear a very high quality version by listening to their Sept 9, 2008 show called "Making the Hippo Dance." Some slightly different quips but the bulk of the presentation is the same. Not bad, but less than I had hoped for. At least for the content.

What intrigued me was that there were two roles being played and they were not accidental. On different programs they swap these roles. The roles are "science enthusiast" and "skeptical realist."
The dialogue creates a fascinating space into which the listener can insert himself. So one guy will say something like, "Even though there's no biological basis to race, forensic scientists can determine gender and race from a tissue sample" and then the other guy will say, "Wait wait WAIT! That can't be possible. How can this be?" And then the other guy will slowly reel in his faux resistance friend. The effect is that I get pulled in, too. Great storytelling and I'll bet there's even a name for this rhetorical device -- but all I know about rhetoric is what I just read at the site A Handbook of Rhetorical Devices (maybe I'll attempt a "dirimens copulatio" without being slapped?). But I digress ...

With a major conference address on the horizon, less than 3 weeks hence, I have wondered about how the co-presenters might represent subtly different stances toward grand challenges and great opportunities. Imagine two speakers. One represents the senior, frustrated and demanding person who tries to incite the crowd; the other speaker a younger, joyous, and encouraging fellow who tries to offer insights. The former could insist that the solution is to tear down the temple while the other might point to rays of hope that might affect changes from within. The former could rant about shelves of volumes and issues of publications that have had little affect; the latter could suggest that there are voluminous issues that demand our attention. One could propose a revolution against the traditional conference; his foil could point to gentler efforts of resistance that are less destructive? Missed opportunities and wasted efforts ... or greater clarity about what we should do and fresh commitments to doing these kinds of works.