Showing posts with label metaphor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label metaphor. Show all posts

Monday, December 19

journey preparations

The backpacking trips I've taken in the past few years have involved renting or borrowing or using cast-offs of other people's equipment. Zero gave me his old backpack, his pre-teen daughter has somehow been tricked into letting a geezer use her sleeping bag, and lodging has often come from a poor old guy who is too busy enjoying his new wife to give his tent proper use. My headlamp and flask were gifts. And I've even had to borrow other's bear canisters to keep the wildlife out of my food. Because camping has become a renewed annual tradition, I feel justified in acquiring my own equipment. Earlier this week, I inadvertently ended up in an REI store where I bought a new membership and my first sleeping pad, yet another vital piece of equipment I'd had to charm away from somebody else. The directions indicate the pad should not be stored all rolled up so it rests under our bed, partially inflated, and its presence has infused my dreams.

My mind is already thinking about gear for next summer's trip. Having always borrowed stuff, there has not been much advanced preparation beyond stashing spare undies and socks into ziplock bags. As I consider what type of sleeping bag and tent I need, I find myself weighing options that previously had not been part of my preparations. Before, I knew I'd get by with whatever color, weight, or sizes were presented. Now, I wonder whether a creamsicle orange sleeping bag is a good idea or not. The price is good, the filling is down, and the weight is low. Can I sleep with something so incandescent? Then there are the tents where "comfort" will be determined by some odd equation that juxtaposes weight against roominess.

None of these internal debates are troubling. I do wonder whether my desire to be toasty warm justifies the extra weight and expense of a bag that is rated for 15°F or colder. Similarly, once I know I can sit upright in a tent so I can put on socks, does it really matter how much space there is on either side of my sleeping pad? It's not like I require floorspace for a library or rock collection or multiple outfits. However, what strikes me is that having the choice of equipment prompts me to consider what is necessary and what is just convenient. Frankly, it's a great mental distraction. I envision a discretely colored tent concealed among the brush. I hold onto the dream of having no equipment lashed to the outside of my pack. I squirm at the notion of my pillow (last year's only equipment buy) nestled inside a large and lofty sleeping bag.

What does prevent me from falling asleep is wondering how to compel a novice researcher to nominate a theory – any theory – as a useful cognitive tool as she descends into a the swamps of interview transcripts. Because she has never had to find her way out on her own, she does not appreciate just how important it is to have packed the right equipment. She's got a canvas bag thrown over her shoulder that holds a digital recorder, a new notebook, and a rainbow assortment of sticky notes. Those will work fine only if nothing unexpected arises. And if nothing unexpected arises, then the journey was not worth her trouble. Had she taken advantage of previous research opportunities, then she might lay awake wondering whether there are sufficient tools for sorting through the mess of data. Or she might even have a couple of tools to consider and will make a final decision as conditions warrant. Unfortunately, the choice she appears to be making is the glorious presumption that the interviews and concept maps will all coalesce around intriguing and meaningful concepts. To distract myself from that impending disaster, I wonder whether I can find something like an Adirondack tin cup that would bring an East Coast flair to the Sierra and Cascade cups that jostle for hot water each morning.

Saturday, January 1

reaching an end

Endings and beginnings are very odd pairings. In some cases, a beginning is loud and dramatic while the end is indefinite and discrete. Examples include human life (the screaming moment of birth and the quiet exhalation at death) and the calendar year (fireworks for January 1 compared to a flipped calendar page for December 1). We celebrate new arrivals and weep at the departures.

In other cases, the transition from start to finish is a crescendo with the UConn Women’s Basketball team as a poignant example. Under great national attention, Stanford ended the Husky win streak at 90 games. [It was surreal to watch Condoleezza Rice celebrating, maybe vindicated for her failed Iraq efforts?] In contrast, our local PBS station just re-broadcasted the first game in the streak from November 16, 2008. It was a very typical game with no one sensing where it might all conclude, and nobody imagining that it would almost 1000 days later.


Each year, the media lists the more famous who have walked among us but have died over the preceding 12 months: actors, scientists, artists, etc. Almost inevitably, we are surprised to discover someone’s passing. People like the woman who played the wife and mother on Leave it To Beaver have been such a presence over the years that it is almost as startling to realize that she is a living person as to simultaneously discover that she is, finally and forever, not. As struck as we can be by an ending this is often followed by the sense that things continue. Maybe we believe the UConn win streak would go on forever, despite the coach making it clear that someday it would have to end. We were fooling ourselves into believing that there might be a basketball doxology:
As it was in the beginning
Is now, and ever shall be,
World without end …
On the night of the famous loss, I went to bed heavyhearted with condolences arriving through the ether. And the next morning we realized we were going to be okay. The coach was quick to recover, quipping at the post-game press conference: “This losing stuff is getting old: I hate it.” Other basketball games are on the schedule and we have six pairs of tickets on the refrigerator waiting to be used — including the first appearance by the team after their spanking by the Cardinal.

What remains unclear is whether anything new really begins and if endings are especially final. Stephen Jay Gould himself charted this by examining time as an arrow or as a cycle. In relation to geology, he appreciated the dichotomy of the metaphors and praised the tensions it generated. And that worked well for Dr Gould in his professional life; in his personal life he has ceased to be. And yet, he persists in his works which continue to education and enlighten.

An acquaintance expressed astonishment that I was not regularly archiving my computer files. I discovered I had the software that just need to be reloaded. The hardware was already on hand but never put into automatic action. I also ran an anti-virus program as recommended and came back with a completely clean bill of technological health. Now I can virtually thumb back through several years of syllabi and manuscripts and conference proceedings. But Time Machine only looks backwards. On January 1st, it is all about possibilities. I am curious to discover a year from now what has been added and what is changed.

Sunday, May 24

like riding a bike

In order for this summer to be a success, it will be necessary for me to engage in activities for which metaphors and similes are useless — like riding a bike. It is its own action and there really is no need to compare it to anything else. To not create metaphors will be difficult, were it not for the fact that I am relearning that I truly like riding a bike. In so much of what I do professionally, having metaphors to rely upon is helpful: diving into the wreck, serving as a day laborer, striving to create a craftsmen's workshop. But gloriously plain tasks don't require further explanation. Creating time with the day to do non-metaphorical activities is a noble goal.

This morning's ride was another out-and-back trip along a segment of a rails-to-trails project. I am setting no records and might be totaling 15 miles on each trek. There were lots of things to notice today:
  • The refreshing coolness when the trail cut through rock outcroppings covered in moss and ferns.
  • An abandoned ball cap perched on a trailside fencepost.
  • The remnants of old railroad ties, also under vegetation, that seemed to pass by as I huffed my way up a gentle slope.
  • A guy in black, wearing sunglasses, walking on an overcast day, in the woods, smoking a cigarette.
  • Noticing the change in grade, not by the incline, but by shifts in the amount of leg muscle exertion and the pace of my heartbeats.
I was tempted to think about what else I do that is like riding a bike or how the things I saw reminded me of other things. Instead, I kept reminding myself that it was just the riding of the bike that was enough on its own. I don't need to compare it to anything else. In the same way, I don't need to extract deeper meaning out of making a damn good batch of sangria with red wine from a box. Nothing inspiring must come from spreading cedar mulch around bushed and perennials. My goal is not to avoid metaphors because there are times where they can be really helpful, such as when I'm inspired to contemplate my surroundings as if I'm inside a whale. I know I should exhibit restraint. When I go backpacking, it is not important that I find ways to use that experience to represent anything else. In the future, more abstract experiences may refer back to such fundamental and unmediated endeavors.
I appreciate the benefits of being in the moment and not trying to read something profound into activities that are important because of their simplicity — like riding a bike.

Monday, April 27

models and metaphors

Although not yet an entry in this blog, for awhile I have been pondering the idea that science educators should rely more heavily upon scientific phenomena as models to explain their research. The very best example I have experienced is the "self-organizing critical systems" model that Andy Hurford once used to describe learning. Briefly, just as each particle that falls onto a sand pile has a statistical probability to cause a structural shift, so too do new experiences have a probabilistic chance of affecting a cognitive rearrangement. Here, a fascinating science concept is appropriate to explain a more elusive phenomenon, namely conceptual change. We should do more of this.

The notion of a pile of free metaphors renewed the potential value of this idea. The contrast is that rather than pulling a metaphor from a bin of "gently used devices" the starting point would be a scientific representation that would be re-cast as a mechanism to explain something. Not that there's anything inappropriate about using a literary metaphor (e.g., "creating a fundable project is like a visit to a cupcake bar") but rather the science metaphor elicits a different type of response — less admiration and appreciation for the cleverness of connections and more about rolling up one's sleeves and getting dirty with the idea.

Recently, a scientist suggested that our stumbling efforts to capture our work might be represented as trophic guilds. A quick search of articles revealed a piece called Insect community composition and trophic guild structure in decaying logs from eastern Canadian pine-dominated forests. The abstract explains that different species of insects are found on rotting logs and that they had different specializations. (This brought to mind the succession of insects found on rotting bodies and how insect evidence is used to solve crimes … but that book has been written and reviewed.) Here we can notice the flaws with appropriating a flawed scientific model and the parallel circumstance wherein a metaphor breaks down:
Of 27 families that were classified as "common" (present in >25% of the logs from at least one decay class), 19 were found to vary significantly in rank-abundance across decay classes, with nearly all of these favouring logs that were either in an early (class I) or late (classes III-IV) stage of decomposition. These associations also reflected functional differences in trophic guild structure: xylophages and predators tended to be most abundant in fresh logs, whereas saprophages, fungivores, predators, and parasitoids tended to be most abundant in more highly decayed logs.
My interpretation of a functioning guild was that it consisted of individuals at various stages and they were traversing along a pathway so some might achieve master status. In contrast, the trophic guilds model depicts workers at different stages that are static. With a downed pine log, the process involves disassembly as material moves from one class to the next. The laborers remain at the same station while the objects are transformed. I believe that the problem with applying trophic guilds to our efforts is that we imagine individuals becoming more skilled as a consequence of their refinement. It isn't the material that is transformed but it is the individual who emerges as a new product as a consequence of being a member of the guild.

Perhaps therein resides some of the utility of trying out new metaphors and models, namely it makes clear what it is and what it is not. In terms of conservation efforts in the natural world, the trophic guild notion is effective for planning what to do with rotten logs as well as how to accommodate grazers on the African savanna (I can't help but note that in this context the "elephants" are called "megaheribvores"). However, from a sociological perspective, I think the naturalists have misappropriated and misinterpreted the complexity of guilds. The distinctions between craftsmen in a workshop and workers in a factory are substantial. And so I'm grateful for the "usefully wrong" suggestion that Crossroads be equated with a trophic guild. The challenge now is to better articulate what Crossroads is to more clearly distance it from less accurate representations.