Sunday, May 15

matters of trust

One of my former students (and favorite bar-maidens) Ms. A is completing her second year as an inner city science teacher. Her close colleague this year from TFA is leaving so A contacted me about a viable replacement. I instantly thought of Miss B who just graduated last weekend from the same program through which I met A. Added to this is that Principal C is A’s boss and I am a huge fan of his leadership. After B called me to tell me that C was moving ahead to hire her, I stopped by the school and spoke with A about the arrangements.
Me: So you think you can work with Miss B?
A: I’m sure. Both B and I said that even though we just met, we trust you.
This is a major amount of confidence for such an incredibly important decision. As you might expect, I was honored and moved to know that my perspective was so valuable. This exchange also elevated “trust” to an entirely new level for me. Knowing how deeply A cares about her students, how idealistic yet determined B is to become an exceptional teacher, and how committed C is to making his school an exemplar I realized trust is an amazing thing to behold. It is difficult to earn, can be readily dispensed, and has a huge influence upon how we proceed through life.

The research project that is about to get underway posits that the leadership in the school (from the principal as well as teacher-leaders) has a powerful influence upon reductions in science achievement gaps. At first blush, the role of the principal may seem very far removed from the performance of children on a standardized test. However, other researchers have identified tangible and significant influences across this large divide. Our short-term goal is to identify those practices in certain schools that distinguish them from schools where achievement gaps are large. In the long run, my ambition is to help schools with sizable science achievement gaps to turnaround by changing leadership practices and the school organization.

Plenty of researchers have studied trust and I was prepared to follow their lead. But given the comment by A (and B) it seems foolish to reduce trust to something that can be measured with a handful of survey items. Furthermore, I am now uncertain how trust differs from "dependable" or "credible." Others rely upon "psychological safety" or "interpersonal ties." Yes, of course all of these feel as if descriptors of healthy work environments. But does it all come down to something we could label as trust?

I trust those who I go backpacking with that if I have troubles, they’ll help me out — with encouragement, first aid or other assistance. I also expect that they will let me know if I can do anything to lighten their load. When canoeing, I trust the person in the bow to paddle in a way that simultaneously moves us forward but also so I can also anticipate what to do in order to keep us going in the desired direction. I trust I will be charged a fair price and receive the appropriate quality and quantity inside the bottle of the beverage I buy at the corner store. Ultimately, such trust frees me from spending energy to monitor all these exchanges.

I also take solace in those relationships for which I can rely upon not being able to rely on trust. But is dependability all that trust involves? Is trust inherently positive or simply consistent? Also, if trust is at one extreme and distrust is at the other, what resides at the midpoint? Finally (for now) are faith and trust essentially the same. From a research perspective, it is important to stake out clear territory which fully encompassed trust and exclude non-trust. And yet from a human relationship perspective, is the trust identified by A, B and C a truer and better measure that I ought to take into account? It is a tremendous comfort to be going forward on this with collaborators. Not sure I fully trust myself.

Sunday, April 24

religious beliefs lost and found

This winter, I was again struck by how beautiful a great snowfall can be. At worst, a big snow is an inconvenience because it makes it hard to move around. But my life is such that moving about is an option I gladly exploit. When the weather is particularly bad, even my employer cancels work but pays me anyway. And with a very short driveway, shoveling is not only manageable but a welcomed opportunity for exercise.

One realization about snow this year was that its beauty has no purpose. Unlike biological phenomena such as bright flowers, beauty from non-living sources cannot be explained as due to evolutionary forces. Why then does snow exist? It falls with grace, it obscures the dullness of winter, and it offers such delightful recreation. But the reason for snow cannot be explained by the same tropes we use in biology. There are no adaptive benefits to snow’s softness or brightness.

I can excuse non-biologists for believing in a higher purpose. As long as I mainly attend to phenomena such as migration or photosynthesis or sugary fruits, evolutionary processes are sufficient for me to explain nature without resorting to faith. How much harder it must be for physical scientists to find similar purpose in the phenomena that are enchanting to their eyes. For this reason, I can appreciate how religious beliefs have emerged and also why they continue to hold such powerful forces for people even as many of us will privately confess to having lost our religion.


Indoors, this day was not especially different from other Sundays in our house. True, a chocolate bunny appeared on the coffee table and the radio announcer reported that the Pope gave a special service at St Peter’s. Otherwise, it could be any Sunday. Yesterday, the weather was grim: chilly, rainy and gray. I
did a quick run to the local dump to toss bags of dead leaves onto the humongous compost pile. It was misty and smelly and depressing. But out doors, today is not only a complete contrast but is so spectacular it is almost miraculous. Bulbs I shoved into the cold autumn dirt have arisen, transformed into sunny tulips. A hops vine I thought I had transplanted resurrects itself in the place where it once suffered from a lack of sunlight and attention. The air has heft and caresses and squeezes rather than piercing or pricking exposed flesh. We check with amazement each morning to see the lilac outside the kitchen window, first with buds, then with incipient leaves, and now floral clumps with a slightly purple haze. Walt Whitman famously noted the memories evoked by lilac blooms:
In the door-yard fronting an old farm-house, near the white-wash’d palings,
Stands the lilac bush, tall-growing, with heart-shaped leaves of rich green,
With many a pointed blossom, rising, delicate, with the perfume strong I love,
With every leaf a miracle …
It is all quite astonishing, not at all diminished by a knowledge of biological processes. Without theories and facts, days like today would not surprisingly cause people to believe that mystical forces are at play. I respect that even though it no longer works for me. Pagans, priests and poets have much to celebrate on days like today.

Wednesday, February 23

here comes a flood

The story is that a guy who used to work for the NY Times had his wallet stolen from his jacket as it hung in the closet at work. Somebody found it stashed in a wall. Time between loss and find: forty years. It has been quite a while since I've misplaced a wallet. I have eventually found what I lost: in a pair of pants I uncharacteristically hung up or where it slid under the seat of a car. I can empathize with the dull panic and self-recrimination of having lost something so important. Watching the video of the man being reunited with his wallet after so many years took me far beyond what I could have imagined.

But there is much more to this than the return of a wallet. What I had not initially realized was the the office of the NY Times had moved. When the old guy gets out of the elevator, it isn't the same space in which he had once worked. It's all stripped bare, a staircase has been removed, and it's described as an Egyptian catacomb: dark, dusty and ancient. And when the hero finally holds the wallet out to its long-separated owner (at 1:22), the old man exclaims — and turns away. It is obviously his and he can barely believe he is looking at. He gently accepts it into his waiting hands.

Then the scene becomes holy. One reason this is such a fascinating moment is that it is pure, unrehearsed and profound. As he opens the wallet, the ensuing flood of memories and emotions makes him turn, as if to use his back to take the brunt of a wave. The camera maintains a respectful distance. We see him flipping through the images and papers. He talks to what is in his hand, softly like a child would to a small fluffy animal. He continues for a very, long minute. In excruciatingly clear words, he says exactly what we might expect: "I don't know what to say." He isn't tearful. But it hits him hard. It's difficult to know whether he is feeling the power of the reunion. It is not as simple as seeing pictures of people like his father who are long dead. There is something more taking place but we are left to wonder. He does snap out of his reverie but I suspect that's because of the camera's presence. I am fairly confident that when he went to bed that night, the wallet was on his chest and he lay awake for a long time.




I shouldn't guess at what he was thinking. Instead, I can imagine what might go through my mind. At first, I'd be startled by the rush of memories: an old credit card, a newspaper clipping, and so on — the sorts of things I wouldn't have remembered missing. On seeing them, I would feel and hear a clap just above my head as the "gone" and the "here" slapped against one another. Most of all, I expect I would feel warm with recollections but also chilled by the reminder of finiteness. I would bask in the memory of where I was standing when I took the pictures but also staggered by the realization that those moments are gone — and have been for quite awhile. The consolation for me is a scrap of verse. Noticing the advance in years is a reminder of the life we made for ourselves. To not miss what I experienced would be an indication that I may not have lived as I should've or could've. The hurt would be preferred to having no feeling at all:

“The ways we miss our lives are life.”

A Girl in a Library

by Randall Jarrell


Monday, February 21

the blog entry i may never read

The Interweb is an amazing space. Long ago in graduate school, I would spend an afternoon at the library browsing all the journals. I’d walk down one display aisle to the next, picking up whatever caught my eye. For those publications closest to my anticipated trajectory, I’d open the lid behind the display and thumb through a stack of the past year’s issues. Back then, Science Education had red construction paper covers. There were only 6 issues per year, one of which was entirely dedicated to summarizing all science education research from the previous year.

Now I not only read journals from home (albeit not being able to access copies published during my doctoral years -- presumably because they are far too old) but I receive automated updates of new issues. As I was composing this entry, a little chime indicated that the the latest issue of Mind, Brain and Education is now available. Once upon a time, I marveled that an author could cite someone else’s work that was “in press” because that meant it was possible to have pre-publication access. Now, that’s also a routine process for anyone in the field.

On the other hand, there are terrible things one can find online — images that make you wish for a bottle of eye bleach. I have become wiser about not clicking out of fear. For example, some news page indicated that girls are posting videos of cutting behavior for others to see. Not wanting to judge whether these are calls for help or exhibitionism, I really did not want to have those images seared into my visual cortex. I apply similar caution when puppy commercials or dog rescue stories appear on the television set. I am not strong enough and by changing channels or leaving the room, I insulate myself.


One of the great treats these days is when Zero posts a new blog entry. The announcement appears in Google Reader. Most of the time I pounce on it; other times I use it as my reward for moving more mundane tasks from the inbox to the outbox. Today, the subject line was a warning to avoid clicking too hastily. The more I thought about it, the more worried I became. The title sounded more like an elegy* than an entry that would fill me with delight. Instead, something cold and sinister lurked beneath the blue-cheery link. What I was feeling was dread. In a similar vein, I discovered a
poem by Robert Frost that gives me chills for its finality:

"Out, out…" §
He lay and puffed his lips out with his breath.
And then—the watcher at his pulse took fright.
No one believed. They listened at his heart.
Little—less—nothing!—and that ended it.
I suspect that the “a press release in the hands of my mother” will be similarly dreary and disheartening — a moment of greatness and celebration adeptly minimized and mocked with an offhand comment. As I consider that highly likely possibility, I just sigh. Were I to actually read it, I suspect I would cringe and moan. I probably can't resist forever. But I certainly will wait until a warm, sunny and sober moment.
- - - - - -

* The elegy--the traditional poem for mourning--began in ancient Greece as a sad song lamenting love and death, often accompanied by a flute and written in a specific meter.

§ Out, out, brief candle!
Life's but a walking shadow, a poor player,
That struts and frets his hour upon the stage,
And then is heard no more.
~ Macbeth

School Subject Area Scores

This lacks sophistication as a blog entry. But it does give me a chance to post information in an interesting way. The data is from the Grade 5 statewide mastery test. It only spans 3 years because the science test has only been given that long. Not sure what to make of it except for variability in changes between schools and from one year to the next. These particular schools (all pseudonyms) were chose because half had high achievement gaps in science (by Students of Color, % ELLs and low income families) and the other have had smaller gaps — not that anyone (even me!) can tell which is which from this display.

Wednesday, February 16

baseball tribute

Sometimes I envy the die-hard fans of a particular sports team. Me, I like to watch. But I don't have the mind for memorizing players and positions. Maybe if following a team had been a core piece of my childhood, my mind would be wired differently. On the other hand, it is a true fan's inevitable disappointment. Every sport can only have one champion and all the rest are, if we can be honest with ourselves, losers. And yet, I envy those who so strongly identify with teams, especially in Major League Baseball. True, we found ourselves swept up by the Cleveland Indians in the 1990s and even attending a World Series Game in October. It was bitter cold yet we have many memories. This includes the plaintive cry of a young women seated somewhere in the five remaining rows above us, encouraging and reminding each batter how she felt: "We love you Omar! We love you Manny!" They say love conquers all but there just wasn't enough. We lost this game and ultimately the Series to the Atlanta Braves.

It must be the metaphors associated with baseball that explain how deeply many fans embrace it. The video and lyrics below were created as a tribute to a baseball announcer. What touches me is not simply the effort to honor the man and reminisce about one's golden youth. There are lessons and ambitions and promises this artist makes that caught me off guard. In addition to the highlight of his 1995 season during which the baseball announcer calls an amazing final inning win, this musician looks at his life, what he has done, and where he's going. The title quotes the baseball announcer but also how many of us feel when we look back on things and are amazed by what we've seen and heard and felt. The whole video is great as are the lyrics. What I have provided below are just the final few moments which say so much and stand alone.
My Oh My by Macklemore & Ryan Lewis

I don’t really collect cards anymore,
Just a box and some old cardboard.

Memories embedded in the dust,
In the fighters that age
Just like us
Living somewhere off in the drawer.

This is what you make of it
Yeah we play to win
Live it like we’re under
The lights of the stadium.

Fight
Until the day that
God decided to wave us in,
Right.
Until he waves us in.
Not sure that this would appeal to a larger audience as a conference talk. So maybe it's enough to post it here and let others decide what to make of it.