Saturday, July 30

WTR: WTF in ATL?

Apparently the miraculous improvements in Atlanta Public Schools can be explained by cheating. There are many reasons this is disturbing. One is that it undermines the possibility that Americans might be coming closer to the belief that all children can learn. This trend was something that occurred to me when I finally watched Waiting for Superman. While many claims in the film were left unsubstantiated, including the statement that schools of the 1950s were doing a great job but lost their way in the 1970s. It is convenient imagery but not the truth. Regardless, what I most appreciated was that this film makes it much harder for mainstream citizens to hold onto the belief that inner city parents don’t care about their children's education. The other myth eroded by this film was that it is impossible to overcome the burden of poverty when it comes to educating a child. That these entrenched falsehoods are slightly undone by this film was my reason for hope. Perhaps the public would change its perspective about the value of educating all children. That the Atlanta Public Schools were a success was another piece of evidence -- until the curtain was pulled back and cheating was discovered.

By examining student answer sheets, officials can identify unusual response patterns. One metric they use is WTR: the number of erasures changing a Wrong answer to the Right choice. The first indication that cheating might be taking place was when some schools in Atlanta had an average of 14 WTRs on a 40 question multiple choice test. A startling statistic but circumstantial — except that after an investigation of schools with high WTRs in 2009 showed a dramatic drop in erasures for 2010. Sadly, those were accompanied by plummeting scores in some schools. A subsequent investigation (think: "mixed methods") involved interviews of hundreds of people. Many, many individuals confessed to cheating. Sometimes a teacher would tell individual students to change their answers. In certain schools, the principal made it clear that changing student responses was a desirable strategy. There were also reports of “changing parties” in which groups of adults systematically corrected mistakes.

As expected, many see this as evidence that standardized tests are inherently evil and the pressure to raise scores provoke such behaviors. If this is true then the solution would be to simply stop using standardized tests. Somehow I can’t believe that this is sufficient. After all, at some level adults were aware that their dishonest actions were harmful to children. Many who would have received educational intervention services because of low performance were not identified. And yet they and their parents were never alerted to their academic struggles. What puzzles and intrigues me is more than how widespread the problem is but rather that it is proving to be systemic. Evidence is mounting that coercion and intimidation trickled all the way down from the then-superintendent's office and to individual classrooms throughout Atlanta.


A common refrain about reform is the difficulties of making change systemic. The Atlanta situation proves otherwise albeit in an insidious way. Rather than praise the superintendent for influencing an amazing number of people to do things they might not have otherwise done, one wonders whether there is any hope for a similar transformation that is more honorable. Could we realistically imagine energy being invested throughout a large school system that would produce genuine learning gains rather than artificially inflated scores? Or is this an example where a simple solution took hold and spread whereas the more honest approach is so fraught with difficulties that it is naive to expect anything different? I would like to believe that there are leadership lessons to be learned from Atlanta that that would resonate across a school system but by drawing upon the goodness in educators and parents rather than draw out the scheming and self-interested aspects of far too many people.

image © NYTimes: http://www.nytimes.com/imagepages/
2011/07/22/opinion/22letters-art.html

Friday, July 29

parlay view

English has been my language for quite some time. I tend to be in places where it, or some variant, is what everyone is using. The longest time I have spent outside of the USA was during my father’s Australian sabbatical when I was in eighth grade. My Midwestern/Southern ear failed on only a few occasions. It was several months before we realized that the little guy next door, who we and his family called Tiny, was actually christened “Tony.” Similarly, a trip to Ireland was made all that much easier because knowing how to translate in order to ask for the toilet or a beer was not a necessary prelude to using or abusing either one. For the most part, my travels have not been impinged upon by language differences.

The two-week China adoption trek (already five years ago!) was so tightly managed that I never even contemplated trying to acquire any Mandarin. In my role as support staff (aka "the Manny") I would only ever be on the receiving end of messages. It was clearly brazen when I traveled to Colombia with nary a sentence nor even a phrase book. We were confident our host and hostess would translate anytime it was necessary. The flaw in this plan revealed itself when our flight departing from Colombia was cancelled. Nothing like being frustrated and anxious AND mute. My upcoming trip to France promises to offer some linguistic challenges since Lyon is best known for its gastronomy and the associated displeasure with those who attempt to speak only in English.


Beyond plans to tote a French phrase book, I bought an introductory language CD that contains eight, thirty minute lessons. I had to re-listen to Lesson 1 four times before I could follow the introductory conversation. In general, I can mimic phrases with close to the right intonation. However, the stereotype of the nasally Frenchman struck me as far too comical for me to authentically copy. In Spanish while the r’s are rolled, in French there is a preponderance of throat-clearing. My goal was to produce sensible words in a French restaurant, not a sample of slime from far back in my mouth. So I was conflicted: how to sound French without making myself laugh at my own voice.

Having mastered the exchange in Lesson 1, I girded myself for Lesson 2. It turned out to be basically a review and only introduced a couple extra word variations. This was a great distraction since at the time I was driving on an essentially deserted stretch of interstate. I was bored, it was blazing hot outside, and there was no shame in talking to my digitized tutor. In trying to speak loud enough to hear myself over the air conditioner fan, I began to find my voice. Simultaneously, I was realizing there was not a lot of French I was going to master over the next month. The combination of my loud voice and the recognition that I wasn’t on pace to become conversant turned into an increasingly pitiful call-and-response:
CD: Say: “I don’t understand.”
Me: Je ne comprends pas. Je ne comprends pas!
CD: Say: “I don’t understand French.”
Me: Je ne comprends pas le français. Je ne comprends pas le français! Je ne comprends pas le français!
As the volume grew, I was startled by the urgency in my voice. What might have been amusing in my pronunciation was overwhelmed by the earnestness. I believe you would have felt badly for me even if you could not understand my words. The meaning was clear and I felt it to my core. I imagined being at the train station ticket counter, money and schedule in hand, unable to make a purchase to get from Paris to Lyon. I continued repeating the phrase, beating my fist and becoming louder and more plaintive. I envisioned myself rising from my table at a nice bistro, first addressing the waiter and then appealing to the other patrons to take pity on me. Hungry, thirsty, tired, far from home: I don’t understand French!

Thursday, July 7

meeting the new principal

Three or so years ago, in what seemed like a doomed search for schools to pilot test an urban ecology curriculum, I chanced upon an assistant principal at a local magnet school. She had worked in biology labs at Harvard and actually knew E.O. Wilson and Stephen Jay Gould. Somewhere along the way she discovered that urban schools were where she wanted to spend the balance of her career. In the time since I met her, she has completed her doctorate at a Hartford university and also served a one year internship with the superintendent of Hartford Public Schools. This spring, she hit the jackpot: a former preK-6 elementary school is being transformed into a middle school with an expeditionary learning theme. And she has been appointed the principal. She has a muralist updating office walls, a moving company taking out the tiny chairs, her custodians are vigorously emptying the closets, and she is rehiring just 5 of the existing staff while bringing in an additional 30 people. Earlier this week, I had the opportunity to tour her school and witness her interactions with a couple of her staff. The most amazing scene occurred when she suggested we make a candy run before I departed.

We walked across the street and into a classic bodega, the kind most of us have only experienced by watching movies. Just inside the door was the counter on the right, framed by plexiglass. Two local kids were laboring over the candy choices displayed on either side of the cashier’s window and below. Surprisingly there were also fresh vegetables and locally baked bread available to purchase. My friend had been here before and knew where the plain M&Ms and Sour Patch sticks could be found. Understandably, she wants to become known in the neighborhood. While I would have been content to simply observe the confectionery conversations, Stacy asked the taller boy what grade he was in: “Eighth” he answered brightly. His buddy was going into sixth. When Stacy uncovered that they were going to the “new” school across the street, she offered her hand and introduced herself as their principal.

The delight on the boys' faces as they left the store to get on their bikes was something to witness. It was more than the glow of having met a celebrity. Their faces suggested an unexpected eagerness about the next school year. The regular neighborhood school they had attended just a month earlier was being transformed over the summer. It was going to be a new place. And now they had met the lady who was going to be running the place. Excitement, anticipation and hope. Stacy has an incredible amount of work to do between now and the first day of school. Over sandwiches she and a couple of her team members were trying to figure out how to rotate three grade levels through a tiny cafeteria. And then there is the matter of who will supervise the children as they eat. But even with the countless tasks required to physically whip the place into shape, I envy Stacy and am proud that she also noticed the glow that her handshake pumped into her future students. Things are going to be different, things are going to be better, and if I am wise then I’ll find ways to contribute and reap benefits.

Sunday, June 12

boxes

Our town issued each resident a rolling tall recycle bin. Somehow we ended up with two that are emptied on a biweekly basis. Plus the green one for trash that is collected every week. Because of a trip to Maine, we missed one recycle event. It ended up we were clearing stuff from the basement and the boxes and now useless paper scraps filled both blue bins to capacity. The absence of any real work schedule has made it easier to chuck old files. I even found a syllabus from 1993 that I decided I could now discard. But it had to wait until this Friday morning because there was no room at the bin. Saturday, I returned to the basement and making considerable progress with again filling the bins.

Some stuff has to be kept. Now I could probably scan in the old photos of me with Cleveland kids, or with four nieces and nephews on my lap (now all high school graduates) and even before that, photos of my adult Boy Scouts in Illinois. And since some pictures were a little stuck together, it would make good sense for me to spend a day converting those to an electronic format.
Otherwise, when I'm in the retirement home, I'll have no way to recall what color kerchiefs the men in uniform wore nor how cute and innocent the third graders were at the time. I also found a small moose antler and a jester's hat in gold, green and purple … a great deal of junk. Even random pages from an old Far Side calendar. If I don't decide what gets trashed, those dispositions will be determined by some other force, either human or mildew.

None of these feel like cares and woes. But it is strange to find bits that remind me of
experiences I might have otherwise never recalled. I'm not sure whether those reminiscences are valuable. Truly, it's more of a curiosity to stumble across, for example, the list of words distributed during a conference Buzzword Bingo game. Again, nothing profound or revealing. At best, it confirms I was here and maybe indicates that I can appropriate the eulogy offered by Frank Turner: "But on the day I die I’ll say: “At least I fucking tried!”, and that’s the only eulogy I need."

Wednesday, May 18

innocence lost during interviews

Maybe it was innocent. Perhaps it was naive. All I know now is that asking future teachers to speak about diversity can be an intense experience. The conversations were only an hour in duration. Further, the event was bracketed by several formalities. With all of this, there was no expectation of my exhilaration and awe. I suppose I’m waiting for potency to fade before going back to the data. For now, I feel I ought to confess that whatever hint of remote and objective research is gone. The sterile glass container has shattered and I’m shocked by all that has poured forth. Even as it spills over me, it is still too sudden to decide whether the contents are scaldingly hot or bracingly cold. There is a much longer story to be told. But for now, I wanted to report that I had not expected all that emerged.

I made use of the recommended Seidman interview protocol. First, I asked them to describe their experiences with diverse populations, in school and work, prior to entering the program. I then shared with them their responses to the surveys and we looked to see where
their views had changed the most. I also invited them to describe any “critical incidents” (what they renamed as “whoa” or “wow” moments). I had expected and hoped that they would describe a pivotal course reading, classroom debate, or even a confrontation during their field experiences that shook them and shaped their views. While some of that did emerge, there were other revelations and disclosures that caught me off-guard.

One physics student told me that he graduated from the smallest high school in our state and experienced almost no diversity at that time. He recalled, as he was at a private New England school, how he would occasionally see the one black student (a woman) on campus and being struck by her presence. In contrast, his student teaching experience was in the largest high school in the state. He spoke with such respect and admiration for his students that it was hard not to be moved. He was reverential but also quite clear that his direct interactions with individual students shattered any stereotypes he might have had about urban youth. Not everything was ideal and he reported his revlusion when another teacher spoke disparagingly of "those Spic students." Despite that individual, this novice teacher c
ould not have been more complimentary about the students.

Another graduate described growing up in the rural south. She met her future spouse over the web and during a courting phone call, he revealed that he was Jewish. She had no sense about the potential significance beyond this being a religious background. A third revealed that he student taught in his former high school and that he was witnessing a substantial demographic shift, a shift to which not all faculty were responding an in admirable fashion. Another (also physics) was deeply influenced by the notion of hegemony and found Paulo Freire to give him intellectual tools that he desperately needed to make sense of his chosen profession.

Two interviewees were especially striking. Both persons were unknown to me before the interview and yet were sufficiently willing to share their views that we exceeded their one-hour scheduled times with me. The first tearfully described a conflict in a multicultural course where her classmates expressed dismay by her racist comments about Middle Eastern Muslims. They were troubled by her claims that members of that population operate within a culture where human life is undervalued and where violence is an almost expected trait. Truly, her comments sound harsh. My understanding is that the course instructor struggled to manage the explosion of words on that day. But she was tearful during my interview, I believe because she felt so strongly and was not being fully understood. She also explained that she lived in Israel for over two years (as an adult), has gained Israeli citizenship, maintains close contact with folks there, and returns as often as she can. All of this to say that her "racist" comments arose from direct experience. She knows people who have died from attacks. Her views of diversity, while not uniformly accepting, are so much better informed than mine.

The other striking interview was a student who also was raised in a homogenous and privileged setting but was placed in another tough urban high school setting. As with the first student, she developed immense admiration for her students and came to understand why they behaved as they did. But this was accompanied by an ever-growing horror about how adults in the school interacted with the students. The worst offender was her host teacher for reasons I'll reveal some other time. She spoke so glowingly about her students and was so sincere in her efforts to accommodate their language difference and home backgrounds that I asked if those factors were influencing her job search strategies. I was knocked speechless when she said she had decided to not be a teacher but was pursuing a receptionist position in NYC. Her passion for her subject matter (esp. poetry) and her delight with passing that appreciation along to urban students failed to alert me to just how awful the things were that she witnessed. It came down to her host teacher who was devious and manipulative -- yet powerful and well-regarded within her school. That person drove this ambitious and dedicated individual away from the profession.

Beyond their willingness to share, there was a start
ling intimacy that thrilled and frightened me. The stories they told were incredibly evocative and stirring. I became lost in what they were sharing and stopped being a researcher and instead became a witness. I am by how vividly they could relate their experiences and emotions. In addition, they felt free to do so. In turn, i believe I had a physiological response, a combination of the empathy I felt for them in their uncomfortable circumstances as well as a drive to use what influence I have to make things right. But when the stories ended, I came back to the realization that it was just the two of us, separated from everyone else but now simply in a small meeting room. The incident was over despite how powerful it had all been just moments before. And then the interview reached its end. I thanked them for sharing, invited them to select a water bottle, and they shook my hand as they left. I appreciated what they had to say and was pleased that I had been able to create a space for them to feel comfortable talking about their views. But still, the intensity of this encounter startled me and I wonder what to do with the confusion of sensations. I have since discovered that others have written about similar feelings but with much more difficult topics (e.g., survivors of violence or responding to death of someone close). I knew there was something valuable regarding diversity that could emerge from individual interviews. I just had no warning of the immense intensity that would accompany the story-telling.

Sunday, May 15

matters of trust

One of my former students (and favorite bar-maidens) Ms. A is completing her second year as an inner city science teacher. Her close colleague this year from TFA is leaving so A contacted me about a viable replacement. I instantly thought of Miss B who just graduated last weekend from the same program through which I met A. Added to this is that Principal C is A’s boss and I am a huge fan of his leadership. After B called me to tell me that C was moving ahead to hire her, I stopped by the school and spoke with A about the arrangements.
Me: So you think you can work with Miss B?
A: I’m sure. Both B and I said that even though we just met, we trust you.
This is a major amount of confidence for such an incredibly important decision. As you might expect, I was honored and moved to know that my perspective was so valuable. This exchange also elevated “trust” to an entirely new level for me. Knowing how deeply A cares about her students, how idealistic yet determined B is to become an exceptional teacher, and how committed C is to making his school an exemplar I realized trust is an amazing thing to behold. It is difficult to earn, can be readily dispensed, and has a huge influence upon how we proceed through life.

The research project that is about to get underway posits that the leadership in the school (from the principal as well as teacher-leaders) has a powerful influence upon reductions in science achievement gaps. At first blush, the role of the principal may seem very far removed from the performance of children on a standardized test. However, other researchers have identified tangible and significant influences across this large divide. Our short-term goal is to identify those practices in certain schools that distinguish them from schools where achievement gaps are large. In the long run, my ambition is to help schools with sizable science achievement gaps to turnaround by changing leadership practices and the school organization.

Plenty of researchers have studied trust and I was prepared to follow their lead. But given the comment by A (and B) it seems foolish to reduce trust to something that can be measured with a handful of survey items. Furthermore, I am now uncertain how trust differs from "dependable" or "credible." Others rely upon "psychological safety" or "interpersonal ties." Yes, of course all of these feel as if descriptors of healthy work environments. But does it all come down to something we could label as trust?

I trust those who I go backpacking with that if I have troubles, they’ll help me out — with encouragement, first aid or other assistance. I also expect that they will let me know if I can do anything to lighten their load. When canoeing, I trust the person in the bow to paddle in a way that simultaneously moves us forward but also so I can also anticipate what to do in order to keep us going in the desired direction. I trust I will be charged a fair price and receive the appropriate quality and quantity inside the bottle of the beverage I buy at the corner store. Ultimately, such trust frees me from spending energy to monitor all these exchanges.

I also take solace in those relationships for which I can rely upon not being able to rely on trust. But is dependability all that trust involves? Is trust inherently positive or simply consistent? Also, if trust is at one extreme and distrust is at the other, what resides at the midpoint? Finally (for now) are faith and trust essentially the same. From a research perspective, it is important to stake out clear territory which fully encompassed trust and exclude non-trust. And yet from a human relationship perspective, is the trust identified by A, B and C a truer and better measure that I ought to take into account? It is a tremendous comfort to be going forward on this with collaborators. Not sure I fully trust myself.